Bay Island

Siesta Key Real Estate

Browse all homes for sale in Bay Island, a neighborhood in Siesta Key, FL. Check out your options and call or email us if you would like details on any of these properties. You can also click the "Request More Info" button for a quick reply on any property.

Want more information about any of these Bay Island homes for sale? Just click the "Request More Info" or "Schedule a Showing" button when viewing the details of that property. As Siesta Key real estate experts, we not only have access to the property disclosures and past sales history of each property, but the local knowledge to help you interpret them. We can also provide you with dates and prices of nearby homes recently sold in Siesta Key, and more. We are here to make your search easy and stress free!

Bay Island January 16, 2019
8
Listed
140
Avg. DOM
$620.65
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$2,292,500
Med. List Price
8 Properties Found.
Sort By:
625 Norsota Way
Sarasota, FL 34242
625 Norsota Way Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 23
$6,950,000
Subdivision: Bay Island
BEDS
5
BATHS
8
SQ.FT.
6,077
BUILT
2009
ON SITE
101Days
MLS
A4210609
Fashioned after the 200 yr old Pitot House in New Orleans and selected as one of the Top 10 most beautiful homes in Sarasota by Sarasota Magazine in 2016, this 2009 British West Indies designed home...
808 Freeling Drive
Sarasota, FL 34242
808 Freeling Drive Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 25
$2,625,000 ( $475,000 )
Subdivision: Bay Island Shores
BEDS
3
BATHS
4
SQ.FT.
4,852
BUILT
1984
ON SITE
258Days
MLS
A4402294
Popular among boaters and water enthusiasts, this Bay Island Shores location on Siesta Key offers 100' of waterfront property on Roberts Bay. A distinctive home with an impressive great room perfect...
862 Freeling Drive
Sarasota, FL 34242
Open House
862 Freeling Drive Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 49
$2,600,000 ( $100,000 )
Subdivision: Bay Island Shores
BEDS
4
BATHS
4
SQ.FT.
3,002
BUILT
1970
ON SITE
73Days
MLS
A4418207
Enjoy spectacular southern views of Roberts Bay and the intracoastal waterway from this home located on Bay Island on the northern tip of Siesta Key. This 2-story home has 4 bedrooms with 2nd floor...
3650 Flamingo Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34242
3650 Flamingo Avenue Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 50
$2,595,000 ( $100,000 )
Subdivision: Bay Island
BEDS
5
BATHS
5
SQ.FT.
3,978
BUILT
2012
ON SITE
86Days
MLS
A4416613
Casual luxury reigns in this 3,978 square-foot island home, the perfect hub for enjoying Sarasota's sun and fun. Tucked away on Bay Island, between Sarasota's mainland and the north end of Siesta...
3640 Flamingo Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34242
3640 Flamingo Avenue Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 27
$1,990,000 ( $200,000 )
Subdivision: Bay Island
BEDS
3
BATHS
4
SQ.FT.
2,984
BUILT
1991
ON SITE
27Days
MLS
A4422130
Indulge and delight your family with the Florida dream of living the boating and water lifestyle while only moments to the white sands of Siesta Beach. Located on the highly desirable North end of...
530 Freeling Drive
Sarasota, FL 34242
Open House
530 Freeling Drive Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 25
$995,000 ( $112,000 )
Subdivision: Bay Island
BEDS
3
BATHS
2
SQ.FT.
2,152
BUILT
1957
ON SITE
325Days
MLS
A4211101
Located on Bay Island, a premier Sarasota multi-million dollar neighborhood over the north Siesta Key bridge, this mid-century residence with southern exposure is showered in sunlight and sits on a...
3484 Hamilton Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34242
3484 Hamilton Avenue Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 43
$829,900
Subdivision: Bay Island Park
BEDS
6
BATHS
3
SQ.FT.
3,758
BUILT
1984
ON SITE
76Days
MLS
A4417904
This spectacular home on TWO corner lots on Siesta Key is paradise found! Spend your day having fun at the beach or fishing at the park - both are a short walk from your front door. This spacious...
3433 Hamilton Avenue
Sarasota, FL 34242
3433 Hamilton Avenue Sarasota, FL 34242
1 of 16
$595,000 ( $54,900 )
Subdivision: Bay Island
BEDS
2
BATHS
2
SQ.FT.
1,444
BUILT
1967
ON SITE
181Days
MLS
A4408989
Move right in and enjoy this wonderful pool home on Bay Island North Siesta Key. Large caged pool & spa. Screened area is 34'x43'. Very open and entertaining.4 sets of French doors go out to screened...

Need More Info? Contact Us!