Casey Key - Sarasota FL Real Estate

Casey Key, Florida is a secluded and quiet 8 mile long barrier island located approximately 15 miles south of downtown Sarasota in Nokomis. The waterfront properties for sale on this island consist entirely of single family homes. There are no high-rise condos on this barrier island!

Casey Key provides opportunities for luxury and waterfront homes, direct Gulf-front, bay front and even some Gulf-to-bay estates. Mature and tropical vegetation abounds here with sweeping oaks lining the secluded roadways.  Read More...

Browse all homes for sale in Casey Key. Check out your options and call or email us if you would like details on any of these properties. You can also click the "Request More Info" button for a quick reply on any property.

We can also provide you with available disclosures, sales history, dates and sale prices of comparable properties, and more. We are here to help!

Casey Key July 21, 2019
31
Listed
208
Avg. DOM
$913.29
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$2,800,000
Med. List Price
31 Properties
Page 1 of 3
$11,950,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
6
Beds
6F41/2
Baths
10,291
Sq.Ft.
2004
Year Built
172
Days on Site
A4425644
MLS
One of the most magnificent gulf front estates near Sarasota, known as southwest Florida's "cultural coast," Villa de Paradiso overlooks the Gulf of Mexico's crystal waters and is beautifully sited...
$6,499,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
9
Beds
10F11/2
Baths
9,127
Sq.Ft.
1977
Year Built
809
Days on Site
A4185393
MLS
PRICE REDUCED-1.5M-Live like a midcentury Hollywood starlet transported to the modern era in a stunning seaside one-of-a-kind estate. This coveted North Casey Key, 300-foot Gulf of Mexico frontage...
$5,824,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
6
Beds
5F21/2
Baths
7,000
Sq.Ft.
2019
Year Built
167
Days on Site
A4426129
MLS
Pre-Construction. To be built. By John Cannon Homes. Enjoy vivid sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico from this Gulf-front estate site on Casey Key. Add your distinctively designed residence. These images...
$5,650,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
5
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
4,764
Sq.Ft.
1993
Year Built
90
Days on Site
N6105369
MLS
Timeless elegance meets classic coastal style in this stunning resort home. Rich mahogany floors lend an air of colonial British West Indies. The formal entryway provides a panoramic view of the...
Open 7/28
1044 N Casey Key Road Osprey, FL 34229
$5,495,000
Subdivision: Casey Key Association
6
Beds
7F11/2
Baths
6,829
Sq.Ft.
1937
Year Built
47
Days on Site
A4437755
MLS
LAFFIN PLACE... A Gated Bayfront Estate on 1.2 acres on the private North end of Casey Key with deeded access to a private beach to enjoy spectacular sunsets. The property with main house, guest...
Open 7/28
916 N Casey Key Road Osprey, FL 34229
$5,250,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
6
Beds
4F21/2
Baths
5,318
Sq.Ft.
1973
Year Built
376
Days on Site
A4408082
MLS
Location, Location, Location! NEW PRICE! North Casey Key beachfront tropical oasis. 200ft on the Gulf, 2 homes on the beach main residence on the bay. Once on the property you are amazed by the...
$4,525,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
5,037
Sq.Ft.
1993
Year Built
132
Days on Site
R4901550
MLS
LARGE PRICE REDUCTION. BEST VALUE ON CASEY KEY! Why choose between a home on the beach or one on the bay when you can have both?

Awake in the morning to a beautiful sunrise from your large...
$3,999,900
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
4F11/2
Baths
3,571
Sq.Ft.
1986
Year Built
193
Days on Site
A4423196
MLS
The ultimate dream beach house. Positioned directly on the Gulf of Mexico. Experience peaceful privacy beyond the gated entry to lush blooming gardens and Koi Pond. Located on the Island of Casey Key...
$3,950,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
4
Baths
3,358
Sq.Ft.
1957
Year Built
98
Days on Site
A4433398
MLS
Inspired by the rustic sophistication of Adirondack-style architecture, this magnificent Gulf-front home presents a breathtaking departure from the traditional Florida beach aesthetic. Upon entrance,...
$3,825,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
5
Baths
3,202
Sq.Ft.
1950
Year Built
95
Days on Site
A4433785
MLS
Experience all the warmth and charm that this 1950 "Old Florida" beach house has to offer on exclusive North Casey Key. Rarely do you find privacy and exquisite walking beach in tandem. Set on...
$3,800,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
4,096
Sq.Ft.
1969
Year Built
173
Days on Site
A4425715
MLS
Privacy abounds behind the gated entry to this unique Spanish Mediterranean beachfront home hidden away in tropical splendor on the sparkling blue waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Attention to detail is...
$3,540,000
Subdivision: Casey Key
4
Beds
4
Baths
3,462
Sq.Ft.
1975
Year Built
369
Days on Site
N6101230
MLS
REDUCED! 1.5 acre Gulf-to-Bay Priced to sell on Exclusive North End Casey Key. The private beach with no public access is a luxury of privacy that few places offer & is part of the magic of Casey Key....

History of Casey Key

Many years ago, 150 to be exact, the island was known as "Chaise's Key." The island was named after U.S. Army Captain John Charles Casey while he was assigned to remove the Seminole Indians from this area. During Casey's tenure, he assisted the U.S. government with the original coastal survey resulting in his name's placement on the map attached to the inlet south of the island (Venice Inlet). "Chaise's Key" was renamed "Treasure Island" during the 1920s Florida land boom. After the boom turned bust, the name reverted to Casey Key.

Local Resources & Attractions

Casey Key Waterfront Property

Casey Key Beach CabanaCasey Key is a beautiful tropical island south of the Sarasota mainland. Many of the island's homes are private gated estates with Gulf and Bay access. There are a few small cabanas on the beach side of some properties. The island's beach is pristine, and every day is special in this tropical paradise. You'll find properties with incredible waterfront views here. Many celebrities, seeking private estates have made Casey Key their home.

Bougainvillea vines on Casey KeyResidential real estate buyers searching for homes on Casey Key have options that include everything from older ranch-style beach cottages ready for a renovation to elaborate and luxurious mansions draped in tropical foliage. The new homes have all of the sate of the art features that today's luxury buyers demand.

Property Resources

Contact Us Today