Casey Key - Sarasota FL Real Estate

Casey Key, Florida is a secluded and quiet 8 mile long barrier island located approximately 15 miles south of downtown Sarasota in Nokomis. The waterfront properties for sale on this island consist entirely of single family homes. There are no high-rise condos on this barrier island!

Casey Key provides opportunities for luxury and waterfront homes, direct Gulf-front, bay front and even some Gulf-to-bay estates. Mature and tropical vegetation abounds here with sweeping oaks lining the secluded roadways.  Read More...

Browse all homes for sale in Casey Key. Check out your options and call or email us if you would like details on any of these properties. You can also click the "Request More Info" button for a quick reply on any property.

We can also provide you with available disclosures, sales history, dates and sale prices of comparable properties, and more. We are here to help!

Casey Key January 28, 2023
22
Listed
107
Avg. DOM
$1,649.07
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
$4,197,500
Med. List Price
22 Properties
Page 1 of 2
$18,500,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
6
Beds
7F11/2
Baths
11,785
Sq.Ft.
2014
Year Built
275
Days on Site
A4533327
MLS
The barrier island and enclave known as Casey Key offers some of the most exquisite residences along the Gulf Coast. Included in this portfolio of majestic gems includes Tweenwater, an estate aptly...
$13,000,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
6
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
3,414
Sq.Ft.
1949
Year Built
139
Days on Site
A4546715
MLS
Discover your very own "Shangri-la", on one of the most desirable beaches along the West Coast of Florida. Casey Key is where this private beachfront estate awaits your arrival. A once-in-a-lifetime...
$12,000,000
Neighborhood: Palmer
6
Beds
7F11/2
Baths
6,997
Sq.Ft.
1992
Year Built
195
Days on Site
N6122431
MLS
World Class Beach Front Estate located on Casey Key, one of the most private and exclusive barrier islands of Sarasota and Florida's Gulf Coast. Built to entertain guests from around the world, this...
$7,250,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
3
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
4,740
Sq.Ft.
2021
Year Built
97
Days on Site
N6123485
MLS
Dramatic Contemporary Architectural Masterpiece completed Fall of 2021 on the exclusive & private North End of Casey Key with deeded Gulf access. Designed by award winning architect Mark Sulatana &...
$6,900,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
5
Beds
3
Baths
3,086
Sq.Ft.
1916
Year Built
73
Days on Site
A4552859
MLS
Opportunities are endless with this extremely unique 1.5 acre property situated on North Casey Key Road. Watch the sunrise from your private 175' frontage on Little Sarasota Bay (with permits for...
$5,950,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
4
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
4,935
Sq.Ft.
1983
Year Built
142
Days on Site
A4547431
MLS
Rare Gulf-to-bay property with the main home on the bay and guest house on the Gulf of Mexico. The main home has open water views and is set back from the road and along a quiet stretch of Little...
$5,950,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
5
Beds
5F11/2
Baths
5,141
Sq.Ft.
1984
Year Built
76
Days on Site
A4544000
MLS
Fabulous Key West-style home, set back from the road with significant updates and a whole-house remodel that was completed in 2017. Featuring a beautiful main home and separate 2014-built carriage...
$5,750,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
5
Beds
4
Baths
5,053
Sq.Ft.
1949
Year Built
170
Days on Site
A4545093
MLS
This lovely Casey Key Beach house is a classic with timeless style. Located near the north bridge for easy on and off island access and just steps from a private deeded beach easement, where you can...
$5,250,000
Neighborhood: Not In A Subdivision
3
Beds
3
Baths
2,716
Sq.Ft.
2022
Year Built
47
Days on Site
N6124170
MLS
Offering the ultimate in luxurious living, perfectly poised on the Intracoastal Waterway. A home of this caliber rarely hits the market as new construction. With its West Indies exterior and modern...
$4,950,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
4
Beds
3F11/2
Baths
2,380
Sq.Ft.
1969
Year Built
70
Days on Site
U8183072
MLS
Welcome to your very own Gulf front beach home located on one of the most captivating, serene and exclusive barrier islands on Florida's west coast. This custom 4 bedroom 3.5 bathroom mid-century...
$4,400,000
Neighborhood: Not Part Of A Subdivision
3
Beds
2
Baths
1,408
Sq.Ft.
1960
Year Built
4
Days on Site
A4557843
MLS
Fantastic opportunity to own a 3 property compound on the intracoastal waterway in Nokomis. These 3 properties are being sold as one. This is a chance to make this your own family retreat. Great...
$3,995,000
Neighborhood: Casey Key
3
Beds
3
Baths
2,809
Sq.Ft.
1967
Year Built
48
Days on Site
A4554544
MLS
Casey Key bayfront estate, This beautiful home sits on 121 foot of the intercoastal water way. Bring your boats and fishing poles to experience the life style of the key. Entering this home the open...

History of Casey Key

Many years ago, 150 to be exact, the island was known as "Chaise's Key." The island was named after U.S. Army Captain John Charles Casey while he was assigned to remove the Seminole Indians from this area. During Casey's tenure, he assisted the U.S. government with the original coastal survey resulting in his name's placement on the map attached to the inlet south of the island (Venice Inlet). "Chaise's Key" was renamed "Treasure Island" during the 1920s Florida land boom. After the boom turned bust, the name reverted to Casey Key.

Local Resources & Attractions

Casey Key Waterfront Property

Casey Key Beach CabanaCasey Key is a beautiful tropical island south of the Sarasota mainland. Many of the island's homes are private gated estates with Gulf and Bay access. There are a few small cabanas on the beach side of some properties. The island's beach is pristine, and every day is special in this tropical paradise. You'll find properties with incredible waterfront views here. Many celebrities, seeking private estates have made Casey Key their home.

Bougainvillea vines on Casey KeyResidential real estate buyers searching for homes on Casey Key have options that include everything from older ranch-style beach cottages ready for a renovation to elaborate and luxurious mansions draped in tropical foliage. The new homes have all of the sate of the art features that today's luxury buyers demand.

Property Resources

Contact Us Today

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.